Garden City Past Winners
| Year: | Horse: | Owner | Trainer | Jockey |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2012 | Samitar (GB) | Martin S. Schwartz | Chad C. Brown | Ramon A. Dominguez |
| 2011 | Winter Memories | Phillips Racing Partnership | James J. Toner | Javier Castellano |
| 2010 | Check the Label | Lael Stables | H. Graham Motion | Ramon A. Dominguez |
| 2009 | Miss World | Waratah Thoroughbreds | Christophe Clement | Cornelio H. Velasquez |
| 2008 | Backseat Rhythm | Paul P. Pompa, Jr. | Patrick L. Reynolds | Javier Castellano |
| 2007 | Alexander Tango (IRE) | Noel O' Callaghan | Tommy Stack | Shaun Bridgmohan |
| 2006 | Magnificent Song | Parrish,Malcolm,Edward | Todd Pletcher | Garrett Gomez |
| 2005 | Luas Line (IRE) | Mrs. Evelyn Stockwell | David Wachman | John Velazquez |
| 2004 | Lucifer's Stone | Team Solaris Stable | Linda Rice | Jose Santos |
| 2003 | Indy Five Hundred | Georgica Stable | Robert Barbara | Pat Day |
| 2002 | Wonder Again | Phillips & Phillips | James Toner | Edgar Prado |
| 2001 | Voodoo Dancer | Green Hills Farms | Christophe Clement | Corey Nakatani |
| 2000 | Gaviola | Twilite Farms | William H. Turner Jr. | Jerry Bailey |
| 1999 | Perfect Sting | Stronach Stable | Joseph Orseno | Pat Day |
| 1998 | Pharatta (IRE) | Hinojosa Dario | Carlos Laffon-Parias | Corey Nakatani |
| 1997 | Auntie Mame | Lazy F Ranch | Angel Penna Jr. | Jerry Bailey |
| 1996 | True Flare | Juddmonte Farms | Robert Frankel | Gary Stevens |
| 1995 | Perfect Arc | Brazil Stables | Angel Penna Jr. | John Velazquez |
| 1994 | Jade Flush | Condren, et al | Nicholas P. Zito | Robbie Davis |
| 1993 | Sky Beauty | Georgia E. Hofmann | H. Allen Jerkens | Mike Smith |
| 1992 | November Snow | Earle I. Mack | H. Allen Jerkens | Chris Antley |
| 1991 | Dazzle Me Jolie | Jolie Stanzione | Willard J. Thompson | Jose Santos |
| 1990 | Aishah | Helen K. Groves | Flint S. Schulhofer | Jose Santos |
| 1989 | Highest Glory | Joseph Allen | D. Wayne Lukas | Jose Santos |
| 1988 | Topicount | Centennial Farms | H. Allen Jerkens | Angel Cordero Jr. |
| 1987 | Personal Ensign | Ogden Phipps | Claude R. McGaughey III | Randy Romero |
| 1986 | Life At The Top | Lloyd R. French | D. Wayne Lukas | Chris McCarron |
| 1985 | Kamikaze Rick | Theodore M. Sabarese | John Parisella | Angel Cordero Jr. |
| 1984 | Given | Ronald S. Green | Alfino Pepino | Matthew Vigliotti |
| 1983 | Pretty Sensible | John Zervas | George Travers | Alfredo Smith Jr. |
| 1982 | Nafees | Albert Fried Jr. | Richard T. DeStasio | Jorge Velasquez |
| 1981 | Banner Gala | Ogden Phipps | Angel Penna | Angel Cordero Jr. |
| 1980 | Mitey Lively | Tayhill Stable | Doug Peterson | Jorge Velasquez |
| 1979 | Danielle B. | Our Precious Stable | John O. Hertler | Ruben Hernandez |