Tuesday’s Best Bets and Quick Picks: Finger Lakes exactas

Finger Lakes racing scene (Photo by SV Photography)
Handicapper J. Keeler Johnson shares best bets and quick picks for Tuesday, Sept. 23 at Finger Lakes and Horseshoe Indianapolis, including a pair of exactas.
Today’s special offers from TwinSpires include:
- New Players $200 Sign-Up Bonus: Open your TwinSpires.com account using the offer code BET200 to start earning a $200 bonus.
- Assiniboia Downs 25% Double Down: Hit two double wagers to receive a 25% boost on all winning double wagers at Assiniboia Downs each Tuesday in September.
Today’s TwinSpires tournaments include:
- $40 Horseshoe Indianapolis Challenge
- $200 Horseshoe Indianapolis Feeder to 9/27 Churchill Downs KDBC/BCBC Qualifier
- $150 Mountaineer Feeder to 10/4 Keeneland Fall Challenge Qualifier
Double Down @AssiniboiaDowns! 🤩
— TwinSpires Racing 🏇 (@TwinSpires) September 16, 2025
Hit two doubles and receive a 25% boost on all winning double wagers! 💰
📱 Opt in: https://t.co/DtJycCiJg1 pic.twitter.com/uRzHTKDgrg
Best Bets and Quick Picks
Finger Lakes: Race 2: $11,000 Claiming (5 1/2 furlongs on dirt, 1:29 p.m. ET)
#5 Open Soul Autism (5-2) thrived in her first try at Finger Lakes. Shipping in off of races at Keeneland, Oaklawn Park, and Saratoga, Open Soul Again dropped in class for an $11,000 claimer and drew off after a duel to win by 6 1/4 lengths.
That effort earned an 85 Brisnet Speed rating. None of the other horses entered in Race 2 have earned a Brisnet Speed rating that high, so Open Soul Autism has a strong chance to bring her Finger Lakes record to a perfect 2-for-2.
Let’s bet Open Soul Autism to win and key her over #3 Cajunette (3-1) in an exacta.
Selections
- #5 Open Soul Autism (5-2)
- #3 Cajunette (3-1)
- #1 Rubys Mission (7-2)
Wagers
- $15 to win on #5 Open Soul Autism
- $15 Exacta: 5 with 3
Total: $30
Finger Lakes: Race 6: $5,000 Maiden Claiming (5 1/2 furlongs on dirt, 3:25 p.m. ET)
#3 The Crowley Cup (5-2) debuted in a $50,000 maiden claimer at Saratoga. After vying for the early lead, he tired to finish last out of five.
Plunging in class for a $5,000 maiden claimer at Finger Lakes might be all The Crowley Cup needs to visit the winner’s circle in his first start for hot trainer Anthony Ferraro.
#9 Jasonjet (7-2), exiting a third-place finish in an $11,000 maiden claimer at Finger Lakes, can complete the exacta.
Selections
- #3 The Crowley Cup (5-2)
- #9 Jasonjet (7-2)
- #6 Georgeisimportant (4-1)
Wagers
- $20 Exacta: 3 with 9
Horseshoe Indianapolis: Race 6: Maiden Special Weight (one mile on dirt, 4:45 p.m. ET)
The experienced runners in this field of Indiana-bred juveniles don’t appear overly formidable, so let’s place a win bet on first-time starter #7 Tail Gunner (3-1).
Tail Gunner is a son of Tiz the Law, an early-maturing Champagne (G1) winner who sires a lofty 18% winners from first-time starters. A sharp series of half-mile workouts at Horseshoe Indianapolis should have Tail Gunner primed for a competitive debut.
Selections
- #7 Tail Gunner (3-1)
- #3 Midnight Legacy (9-2)
- #6 Airdrop (4-1)
Wagers
- $25 to win on #7 Tail Gunner
Good luck!
ADVERTISEMENT